I've tried the regular wipes, but the charcoal wipes were the best thing ever made. I used Dyper's charcoals diapers and their regular pull-ups for my child's entire life. He's going to be three in December. While I love the diapers and pull-ups, the charcoal wipes were the absolute best, top tier. Thick, soft, effective, fragrance free, everything you want in a wipe. The regular ones aren't as sturdy. Please bring the charcoal wipes back! I'd give a five but they're not as good as the charcoal ones.